Who lost the most, Sajith or the TNA?

By N Sathiya Moorthy

While it is celebrations time for Team Gota and retrospection time for Camp Sajith, it may well be introspection time for the minority communities and their polity that backed the latter – only to lament their decisions within. The list of course includes Muslim and Upcountry Tamil parties in the outgoing Government, but more so for the Sri Lankan Tamils and their political leadership in the TNA.

True, SLMC’s Rauff Hakkeem and Upcountry Tamil leader Mano Ganesan sought of went overboard, at times attacking the Rajapaksas personally while campaigning for Premadasa. But they all have the history of supporting the winner, post-poll, enjoying the benefits of ministerial offices – and also getting things for their people(s), going beyond long-pending political demands of their own.

It is here that the TNA, like the LTTE that facilitated, or forced, their formation, stands out. The TNA now, and predecessor TULF in its time, have also kept out of every government that they had helped form, like the divided Sirisena-Wickremesinghe team, which owes its existence and continuance to the minority votes, especially of the SLT kind. If they thought that they would play king-maker all over again, and use it as a trump-card post-poll (though with no proven track-record), today, they have all been reduced to being jokers in the pack.

It is nobody’s case that the Tamils and other minorities should not receive their care of the constitutional cake, even if belatedly. But where even Sajith Premadasa, the candidate would not venture to contest or challenge rival Gota R, the Tamils, especially the TNA, went too far, and too fast – without giving the candidate of  their ultimate choice enough time to recoup and contest the damage done by them at the Sinhala grassroots-level.

It is not that the TNA leadership did not have options, even those that would have benefited Premadasa more than at present. Their candidate might have well had the cake and eaten it too, if only they were as circumspect as he himself was. It is anybody’s guess why the TNA took its time to take its decision, and yet went overboard to market their man. It would have been enough if they had told their constituency to ‘vote according to their conscience’. The results would have been the same.

Symbolic or what

So obsessed did a vast majority of Tamil voters become that they would vote anyone and anything as long as it is not a Rajapaksa or the symbol his ‘Flower Bud’. As results from the literate, northern Jaffna district, a Sinhala-Buddhist Independent, Ariyawansha Dissanayake, came fourth behind, Premadasa, Rajapaksa (a very distant second) and ‘rebel’ Muslim leader, M L A M Hizbullah, who got caught in controversies after the Ester Sunday serial blasts that claimed nearly 270 lives.

How did Ariyawansha manage to push a Tamil rebel in former parliamentarian M K Shivajilingam and established JVP nominee, Anura Kumara Dissanayake further down the Jaffna district tally, for instance? Ariyawansha was allotted the ‘Eagle’ as symbol. If one were to go by post-counting Tamil social media posts, rural voters in the North, who knew Premadasa’s ‘Annam’ (Swan) symbol either as ‘vaaththu’ or ‘thaara’ got it all wrong.

It is not an impossible construct. As a candidate, Ariyawansha might not have been known even in his own neighbourhood.  Unless he had visited the Tamil areas on any private visit during poll time, there was no way Tamil voters that cast their lot with him would have known him, to be able to prefer him over the rest, including their own man in Sivajilingam.  Incidentally, terms like vaaththu, thaara and annam all stand for swan in the south Indian States of Tamil Nadu and Kerala.

Personal, personalised

It is anybody’s guess why and how the TNA leadership in particular made their political adversity to the Rajapaksas so very personal and personalised. Post-war, they had held talks with the regime of then President Mahinda Rajapaksa, on a political solution, reported limited progress (which was better than no progress, under the circumstances), and yet went about unilaterally attacking the Rajapaksas (alone) for war-crimes and on other accountability issues.

The irony is the Tamils first and the TNA later on did not have any complaints about war-time army commander, Sarath Fonseka (2010), whom they happily voted the same way they have voted Premadasa, now. In between, they had no problem voting for outgoing President Maithripala Sirisena (2015), without even considering the possibilities of his (limited culpability) for being the Minister of Defence during the closing days of the war, and a silent but known ‘Sinhala-Buddhist hardliner’ in his own way.

The Rajapaksas during their second term humiliated the TNA and the Tamil community by extension, when the Government delegation failed to turn up for the aborting round of talks on two successive days without even extending the basic courtesy of informing them that it was off. Or, that is the impression doing the rounds, and no one has refuted or clarified the same over the past five years and more.

Yet, all of it happened (only) after TNA’s new-found spokesperson M A Sumanthiran declared at a news conference that the US-sponsored UNHRC resolution on war-crimes and the like owed it to their own persuasive skills. If the Sri Lankan State apparatus, as different and distinct from the political leadership or the personality of President Rajapaksa, would not have the TNA’s deliberate flip-flop, now under President Gota Rajapaksa, they would have to begin where it all ended – and abruptly.

Controlling Parliament

The TNA can now expect the Rajapaksas to control Parliament, even before the polls become due in August last year. If not, the new President, exercising powers conferred on him by 19-A may go ahead and dissolve Parliament in mid-February, when it becomes due, and advance the parliamentary polls. The chances are that a divided UNP rival in the Sinhala South may be even more demoralised to take on the Rajapaksas-led SLPP-JO.

The long-pending provincial council polls in the North could precede or follow the parliamentary polls, depending on the Rajapaksas’ success in converting their minority in Parliament into a majority before the August polls. It could well prove to be another problem and embarrassment for the TNA, as they are not as sure of their own support-base in localised contexts, as the nation-wide local government elections proved in February 2018.

There may be another add-on problem, now that the Rajapaksas are back in power at the Centre, and the EPDP of Douglas Devananda may have a ministerial berth reserved for the self. If so, the honourable and the one-way support that TNA mayors received in local government institutions in the Tamil North may become a thing of the past. It could have a deleterious effect on the TNA at the grassroots-level governmental institutions ahead of parliamentary and PC polls.

But they all have a limited impact on the Tamils at large when compared to the stalled constitutional reforms, which the TNA was selling them with no hope of being able to take forward from the Steering Committee. The Rajapaksas had boycotted the process after voting for converting the current Parliament into a Constitution Assembly. So, the Steering Committee Reports could at best get added to the TNA’s five-report demand for consideration on political reforms.

If and when the Rajapaksas started off on the peace process, the chances are that they might go back to their own era, as most participants from the two sides are around and active. The question would then be if the TNA would want to participate, if the SLMC could work out internal solutions to the re-merger issue, and if the TNA can also persuade the UNP friend to participate. The last time under the Rajapaksas, the UNP deliberately stood away along with the JVP, citing reasons that were childish.

None of it would just now be on the Rajapaksas’ mind, starting with that of President Gota can be busy with Government-formation, ensuring parliamentary support and/or elections, and telling allies that they were no more ‘JO’ or Joint Opposition but were the Treasury Benches. They, and also the UNP, would be busy preparing for the parliamentary and PC polls, the latter patching up internal differences that did come out in the open in the choice of party candidate.

It’s all going to take some time, and it can also be the time when the TNA could introspect, rework the priorities of the Tamil community and their own leadership, instead of living for and off one section of the Sinhala majority and another from the ‘international community’, still. In between, if murmurs of protest from within become louder, blaming it all on the leadership and also certain sections thereof, if only to distance the complainant(s) from it all, the Tamil voters have seen them all – only this time, it could actually weaken their political leadership more than on earlier occasions, and for real!

(The writer is a Distinguished Fellow and Head-Chennai Initiative, Observer Research Foundation, the multi-disciplinary Indian public-policy think-tank, headquartered in New Delhi. Email: sathiyam54@nsathiyamoorthy.com)

5 COMMENTS

  1. Sri Lanka is almost divided into two sections 53% voting for Sinhala Buddhist ideology and 47% against such an ideology. This also shows at least 35% of Sinhala Buddhists do not like the southern religious fundamentalist ideology. The first duty of the new President should be to bring about “We are all Sri Lankan ideology”, irrespective of race and religious differences. He should ensure the Southern Buddhist Fundamentalists should be put in their place. If the President can do this then automatically the “fears” in the minds of the minority communities will vanish and the true “we are Sri Lanka” mentality will develop. Its always the majority actions that make the minorities agitate. President Gotabaya has a very good opportunity now to use his new found popularity and take immediate action for the betterment of all Sri Lankans. If he does not do it now, within a short window of opportunity he has before the general election the divisions will further aggravate and would result in international involvement.

    • “President Gotabaya has a very good opportunity now to use his new found popularity and take immediate action for the betterment of all Sri Lankans. ”
      This guy is 70 years old racist and more than half of his life, has been spent conspiring for power, feeding BBS, Sinhale, Karuna, KP, Saharan, Pilleyan……… He used the 2005-2015 period to do what he enjoyed doing by releasing his anger & hatred bottled inside. What he did to SF and other security forces personnel and Lasantha,……..& the rest was inhumane, displaying actions of killer mentality. This family will ruin the country & the nation without a doubt.
      “If he does not do it now”
      He could have done it after defeating the LTTE in 2009. Expecting miracles?. Some say, ‘Miracles do happen’, but not in ‘Sorry Lanka’, even in a million years.

  2. My dear Sathya Moorthy, (Sathya= Truth, Moorthy= Mirror, Satue

    Before long, there will be a definite change in population’s statistics in ethnic diversity in ‘Silly Lanka’ as the hungry, idiotic and ignorant ‘Sinhala Buddhist’ ( I am also a Buddhist, but follow the teaching of the Bhawath Gothama, Enlightened One’ from India) can not afford to have more than one or two children in a family.
    I of course am working toward the ‘Sunyatha’ and if for some reason, had to be born again, pray not to be born among these ‘Mithya Drushtika, Asathpurisha’ nation ever again.

    • Yet a crying complaint from a bu**hurt liberal Buddhist. At least learn to spell “Bhagawath” properly next time. So the majority of Sinhalese voting for their leader is the crime while the overwhelming majority of Tamils and Muslims voting for their leader to fulfill their dreams is the democracy. Hypocrisy at its best. I hope your wish come true and never born in Sri Lanka

      • ‘Bhgawath, Bhawath, Bhagyawath’……and many in the vocabulary more as it is just a label according to ‘Nama/Rupa’Parichcheda’, if you know what that is. I forgive you for accusing me as a “bu**hurt liberal Buddhist” due to your lack of knowledge in ‘dead languages’ like Latin, Sanskrit or even Maghadi.

        “I hope your wish come true and never born in Sri Lanka” .
        Thank you Roshan for your wish and sooner the better. ‘SUWAPATH WEVA’ my son. Metta!

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.